Dark UX Design: Leveraging User Research To Mislead

7 months ago
Dark UX Design: Leveraging User Research To Mislead Image

As app developers, we often talk of the importance of user experience (UX) design, but in this post, our hope is to make you aware of its less noble counterpart, dark UX design. Dark UX design, or dark patterns, are features of interface design crafted to trick users into doing something they might not want to do, but which benefit the business in question.

As a refresher, UX design, at its best, anticipates users’ needs and objectives, as well as their assumptions and behaviors, in order to increase the usability, accessibility, and enjoyment of a product. Typically, creating such benefits for the user also ultimately benefits the company, as the product is often more successful as a result.

Dark UX design also seeks to understand the user and make intentional, well-crafted design decisions. Unfortunately, as noted, the aim of these decisions is often to persuade, mislead, or otherwise encourage the user to partake in the company’s objectives, perhaps to the detriment of their own.

As the rules of an ever-changing technology industry continue to evolve, we are seeing consumers push back against such design choices, essentially asking designers to hold to high ethical standards. They are demanding transparency and accountability—the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is a perfect example of this, with its emphasis on privacy by design.

Examples of Dark UX Design

Dark UX design can vary in its functionality, look, and purpose. Not to be confused with “bad” design, dark UX design also anticipates the user’s objectives, assumptions, and behaviors. However, as noted by Adventures in UX Design, dark UX design will use this knowledge “in direct opposition to concepts we celebrate in design, such as empathy, human or user-centered, and inclusivity. Dark patterns rob customers of their agency.”

DarkPatterns.org identifies a dozen different kinds of dark patterns. They range from what they call the “Roach Motel,” where it is easy to get into a certain situation, but hard to get out of it, to “Disguised Ads,” where adverts are disguised as other types of content or navigation in order to prompt you to click on them. (Think of that ad with the big “Download Now” button…)

Many dark patterns are simple instances created to keep you subscribed, sold, or sharing your data. In the example below, what seems like a basic checkout experience hides a dark pattern. The company has chosen to hide pertinent information for the user within the “More info” tab. If expanded, the user will find that the product defaults to signing them up for both emails and mail from the company, as well as their “carefully selected partners.”

This is possible because the company understands user psychology and behavior and anticipates that many users will fail to expand the “More info” tab. The default selection will allow the company to accomplish its objective of signing users up for promotions while ignoring the fact that most users probably don’t want to start receiving these offers. A more straightforward and user-centered approach would be to leave this button unchecked and let the user opt in if they wished.

Dark UX 1
Often, dark design patterns are created through the interface design elements. Here, the user has clearly chosen to delete their account. While it is certainly good practice for the company to confirm this desire, this company is seeking to thwart the user’s intent by leveraging color to its advantage, a dark pattern often called “Misdirection.”

Typical user behavior for this interface dictates that a user is likely to tap the dominant, blue button with the assumption that it will complete the action they have started. By displaying “Cancel” on the blue button, the company reinforces its objective of keeping the user’s account intact, while ignoring the most likely objective of the user at this point.

Dark UX - Misdirection
Dark UX patterns can also occur simply within the verbiage that an app uses. In the example below, you can see how the wording might be confusing to a user. Lengthy explanations, double negatives, and other wording tricks exploit the user’s likely behavior of skim reading or, at the very least, cause confusion that can result in an unwanted action. A straightforward “Sign me up to receive product updates, upgrades, special offers, and pricing” would be much more beneficial and clear to the user.

Dark UX - Obscure
The consequences of dark design vary, for both the user and the company. Companies like Facebook, Twitter, Google, and Uber continue to face scrutiny and heightened accountability after dark UX patterns have been brought to light. LinkedIn paid $13M in damages after using dark patterns in their onboarding process to try and trick users into surrendering their email contacts.

Most UX Design is NOT Dark UX Design

Dark patterns often get utilized for short-term gains, such as increasing the number of newsletter subscriptions or bumping revenue. While “the numbers” might look good for a brief time, we believe that great UX design that acts ethically on behalf of your user is ultimately good for your company and brand, too.

Thankfully, most reputable developers conduct user experience research for the consumer’s good. How? From the very start, they approach the project with a user-centric perspective. At InspiringApps, for example, you will often hear our team ask questions like “Will they want to create an account right away?” “How many times a day do we expect them to open the app?” and “What will they need to have accessible without a Wi-Fi connection?” User-oriented questions like these lay the groundwork for the app’s user flow, user personas, use case scenarios, and technical requirements. All of this occurs during the Discovery phase of our development process.

Design decisions will be made anticipating a user’s most likely objectives as well as their most likely behavioral patterns, resulting in a great user experience that will allow the user to navigate smoothly and intuitively through the app. Consideration is given to each part of the app throughout the process, whether it be the initial navigational planning, the interface elements, or the verbiage and tone used throughout the product.

The value of designing with the user in mind should not be underestimated at a time when people are more skeptical than ever. Companies that seek to build trust with their users by using straightforward design will have greater success in the long run.

If you’re interested in staying up-to-date on important topics like this, as well as other new technologies impacting mobile, we encourage you to sign up for our monthly newsletter!

Build a product that will delight your users & help your business thrive

We partner with inspired companies to create digital products that delight our clients’ customers and improve business outcomes. We work with our clients to bring their ideas and dreams to fruition. And, our development process is guaranteed to get you to the finish line.
Recent Posts

App Design

Key UX Design Trends for 2024: Exploring the Future of Digital Experiences

As technology progresses exponentially, users’ needs and behaviors evolve as well. Continuous innovation in areas like AI, personalization, and accessibility are driving meaningful changes in UX design trends and digital experiences. In a recent article featured on Built In, InspiringApps’ UI/UX Designer, Becca Collins, provided an inside look at how we build customer-centric trends at the heart of our UI/UX design. Customer-Centric: The focus for 2024 and beyond will center around creating more straightforward, secure, and personalized access for all through a customer-centric mindset.  Personalized: Designers can gain unprecedented insight into individual preferences and behaviors by leveraging data and emerging techniques like conversational interfaces to tailor interactions anticipating user needs. Inclusive: At the same time, inclusive practices and intuitive interfaces will help break down barriers so people of all abilities can engage fully with the digital world.  Empowering: This confluence of UX design trends presents an exciting opportunity for user experience to advance in a way that places proper user understanding, empowerment, and delight at the forefront of design. Designers take note—here are the latest trends in UX design. The Rise of Customer-Centric UX Design Trends In today’s digital landscape, users have come to expect nothing less than seamless and highly personalized experiences across all platforms. As a result, UI, UX, and CX as whole have shifted towards prioritizing the user’s needs, preferences, and behavior and using user feedback to iterate and improve the experience. With this philosophy, design exists mainly to help users navigate and use apps. In customer-centric UX design trends, the experience and the design are two sides of the same coin. When businesses understand and cater to these aspects, they can create engaging and satisfying interactions that leave a lasting impression. From intuitive interfaces to personalized recommendations, the focus is on delivering exceptional user experiences that foster loyalty and drive success. These UX design trends all contribute to the shift to customer-centric design. Here are a few that will make the most significant impact on UX design trends in 2024: Enhanced Personalization Through Data The personalization era is here, as we leverage user data and analyze behavioral patterns to create tailored interactions. Applying individuals’ preferences, data, interests, and needs, we can design experiences that resonate personally. Companies like Netflix and Spotify have taken this UX design trend to a new level, offering delightfully personal user experience at every step, driven behind the scenes by users. Advanced customization carefully crafts every interaction to meet users’ unique requirements and expectations, ultimately fostering deeper engagement and satisfaction. Security Meets Simplicity In today’s digital landscape, multi-factor authentication, biometrics, and encryption have emerged as invisible layers of protection. These advanced security measures seamlessly blend into our everyday lives, ensuring safety without compromising user experience. But in addition to keeping harmful agents out, security must be frictionless for app users. Individuals can confidently navigate the digital world by leveraging these cutting-edge technologies, knowing their sensitive information remains safeguarded from potential threats. Designing for All Inclusive design principles aim to ensure equitable access for diverse groups of users, regardless of their abilities, backgrounds, or preferences. Accessibility is more than an optional box to check. It’s the right thing to do for all consumers.  By considering various perspectives and incorporating inclusive design features—including alt text, high contrast and text size options, and imagery reflecting diversity and inclusion—designers can create products and experiences that are accessible to everyone, fostering a more inclusive and empowering digital environment. Accommodating the Aging Population Inclusive design principles ensure that technology remains accessible, engaging, and beneficial for individuals of all ages, creating a more inclusive digital world. As technology trickles down through all aspects of life, UX design is evolving to accommodate the aging population. Older adults may face unique challenges such as vision and hearing impairment, reduced dexterity, or cognitive changes, impacting their interaction with digital platforms. To create a seamless, no-friction user experience for them, designers must incorporate features like larger text sizes, high-contrast color schemes, and simplified navigation. Implementing assistive technologies such as text-to-speech and speech-to-text aids can significantly enhance the digital experience for the hearing and visually impaired.  Microinteractions That Delight Subtle cues and feedback are essential for enhancing functionality and providing moments of delight and discovery. These small but impactful details can guide users seamlessly through an experience, making it more intuitive and enjoyable. By incorporating these elements, we can create an interface that meets users’ needs and surprises and delights them along the way. Microinteractions are the secret sauce of user interfaces (UI). They are the small but powerful details that boost user engagement by offering instant feedback. From charming icons to delightful animations, these intricate elements inject life into your product, making it irresistibly appealing. Weaving Stories Through Experience Exploring the fascinating art of design narrative and storytelling goes beyond aesthetics and delves into emotional connections and deep engagement. By meticulously crafting seamless and captivating product journeys, designers have the power to create experiences that resonate with users on a profound level, leaving a lasting impact. Considering how we want users to feel when using our websites or apps is an integral part of storytelling through design. We can guide users toward specific actions by evoking emotions like joy, sadness, excitement, or grief through compelling copy and imagery. As we move forward, UX trends will continue to evolve and adapt to incorporate new technologies, enabling us to anticipate better and meet users’ needs, ultimately reshaping digital products to revolve around the human experience. By focusing on enhancing usability, accessibility, and overall user satisfaction, we can create digital experiences that truly resonate with people and make a positive impact on their lives. The Future of UX Design Trends As we continue to push the boundaries and push ourselves as designers, it’s crucial to consider different generations’ diverse needs and preferences. Whether it’s Baby Boomers who value ease of use or Gen Z who prioritize customization and personalization, understanding what matters most to each age group will be vital in creating successful digital products. Designers and developers should continue to observe, research, and learn from our users as we strive to create incredible designs that make a difference in people’s lives.

3 months ago

App Design

Decoding Key Terms in UI UX Design & Customer Experience (CX)

In the fast-paced digital product development world, understanding UI/UX design nuances and the critical role of customer experience is essential. Digital products continue to evolve, fueling an increased emphasis on the user perspective. It’s time to deepen our understanding of these widely used—yet frequently misunderstood—terms: UI, UX, and CX. UI, UX, & CX Defined From the visual elements comprising interfaces to a holistic evaluation of a product’s usability, from a product’s interaction efficiency to the more significant, more encompassing perception of a customer’s interaction with a brand—UI, UX, and CX are critical terms that shed light on diverse perspectives of product development and design. UI: User Interface UI, or user interface, is the point at which the user interacts with a digital device or product, such as a mobile app, website, or software application. It encompasses all the elements users interact with—the screen, pages, buttons, and icons—ensuring an intuitive and efficient experience. Focus on User Interface (UI): UI refers to the visual elements and interactive components that users directly engage with. It encompasses the design aspects that draw users’ attention and guide their interactions within the interface. Examples of UI in Action: When designing a user interface, consider elements such as buttons for user interaction, icons for visual representation, menus for navigation, layout for structuring content, color scheme for aesthetics, typography for text presentation, and animations for enhancing user experience. Goal: The objective is to design and develop a visually captivating, user-friendly UI that looks appealing and ensures users’ ease of navigation and comprehension—a marriage of form and function. User interface (UI) concerns the visual layout and look of a product’s interface, which might be through a website, app, or software. UI design involves the aesthetics of a product—the typography, color schemes, button designs, and layout that form the overall look and feel. Understanding UI Design Principles UI design iterates upon user experience (UX) design by implementing visual elements that enhance usability and intuitiveness. UI/UX designers meticulously apply intuitive navigation and clear information hierarchy through a consistent and unique visual language that helps cultivate brand identity and sets a digital product apart from its competitors. First Impressions: The UI is often the first thing users experience, so it must be visually appealing and easy to navigate. Usability: The UI should be intuitive and easy to use, even for users who are not familiar with the product or service. User Satisfaction: A well-designed UI can make users feel more satisfied and engaged with the product or service. Brand Identity: The UI can help to communicate the brand identity and values of the company behind the product or service. UI design plays a vital role in all of the above. It is crucial in creating usable, enjoyable, and aesthetically pleasing user experiences. “UX and UI are often paired together because it’s often the same position working on those two things. When you start with user experience design, it will then turn into the user interface design that completes the whole product.” —BECCA COLLINS, UI/UX DESIGNER | INSPIRINGAPPS User experience (UX) design focuses on creating seamless, intuitive, and valuable user interactions with products and services. It optimizes products for effective use through understanding user needs, capabilities, and business goals. UX designers aim to enhance the quality of user interactions and perceptions. UX: User Experience Focus: User experience refers to a user’s overall experience when interacting with a product. It encompasses the product’s emotional response, functional effectiveness, and usability aspects. A good user experience ensures users can easily navigate the product, find what they need, and enjoy using it. It is essential for building customer satisfaction and loyalty. Examples of UX in Action: Some key aspects to consider in UX design are ease of use for intuitive interactions, efficiency for smooth functionality, learnability for user-friendly experiences, accessibility for inclusivity, user journey mapping for understanding user pathways, and user research for informed decision-making. Goal: The primary objective is to design an enjoyable, user-centric, and efficient product that not only meets but exceeds the target user base’s needs and expectations. User experience (UX) design focuses on improving user experience through product interactions. User experience (UX) is more than just interacting with a product. It aims to enhance the user experience by simplifying each step of the users’ journey, ultimately making their interaction more straightforward and enjoyable to achieve desired tasks. Enhancing User Experience in Digital Products Improving the user experience in digital products is crucial in captivating and retaining users. Strategies like the following are crucial for designers and developers aiming to elevate the UX of their digital offerings. Ease of Use: Intuitive design and clear information architecture guide users through the product effortlessly. Efficiency: Streamlined workflows and minimal friction ensure users achieve their goals quickly and efficiently. Emotional Appeal: Emotionally appealing design elements create a positive association with the product, fostering loyalty and advocacy. Digital app designers aim to simplify the user’s journey. By prioritizing ease of use, efficiency, and emotional appeal, UX designers can create digital products that are functional, enjoyable, and memorable, leaving a lasting positive impression on users. UX is a part of the broader CX realm. In digital product development, there’s a clear relationship between UI, UX, and the overall customer experience. CX: Customer Experience CX, or customer experience, refers to consumers’ broader experience with a company’s digital products, including websites and applications. It includes every aspect of a company’s offering, from the usability and functionality of its products to the emotional responses they evoke. Focus: The entire customer journey and overall brand perception, encompassing interactions with marketing, sales, support, and the product itself. Examples of CX in Action: Strategic areas where businesses can focus their efforts include customer service interactions, streamlining the onboarding process for new users, effective brand communication strategies, timely product updates to meet customer needs, and fostering community engagement initiatives to build a loyal customer base. Goal: A customer experience (CX) designer aims to build lasting customer relationships by providing exceptional products and personalized services that meet their unique needs, fostering loyalty and advocacy. Customer experience (CX) is a comprehensive term that goes beyond just digital interactions. CX represents the full journey a customer embarks on with a brand. It is a digital customer journey spanning various facets like sales, marketing, and customer service, including online and in-person interactions. CX design provides consistent, positive, and memorable customer experiences that shape their perception of the brand. CX design goes beyond the digital realm of UX in capturing customers’ feelings across multiple touchpoints and channels, including the brick-and-mortar store experience and more. Creating a Successful Customer Experience  Creating an exceptional customer experience requires a holistic approach beyond offering individual elements like onboarding, customer support, and value. It’s about weaving these elements into a seamless journey that delights customers at every touchpoint. Onboarding: A welcoming and guided onboarding process that helps new customers understand the product’s value and functionalities. Customer Support: Prompt, efficient, and helpful assistance is provided to customers when they encounter problems or have questions. Value: Ensuring customer journey and interactions bring considerable value to users. “I’ve used personalization in a meal planning app for people with disabilities. The content presented in the app is highly dependent on the user’s unique profile and needs set up during onboarding. Clear actions are suggested based on the time of day.” —BECCA COLLINS, UI/UX DESIGNER | INSPIRINGAPPS Personalization is a key design trend that makes the product feel more like a companion than a stale or complicated experience. Combined with onboarding and support, it helps to build a deeper relationship with users and achieve long-term success. The Difference Between UI, UX, & CX Understanding UI, UX, and CX is essential for designing digital products that look good, work well, and build lasting customer relationships. UI is a subset of UX. The interface is the tangible manifestation of the UX, making it a crucial component but not the sole factor in user experience. UX is a subset of CX. UX focuses specifically on the product experience, while CX encompasses the entire customer journey and relationship with the brand. All three work together. A successful digital product requires a holistic approach that integrates UI, UX, and CX considerations to deliver a seamless and satisfying experience for users and customers. Real-World Examples of UI/UX Design & CX Improving the Digital Customer Journey in Real Estate The award-winning inHere app provides an excellent case study of how UI, UX, and CX create a user-friendly interface and an enhanced user experience, which is essential for improving UI/UX designs. 1. Standout UI Features Buttons, icons, and menus provide easy navigation for managing transactions. A visually appealing color scheme, typography, and illustrations enhance the look and feel. The intuitive layout makes complex tasks manageable and efficient. 2. Standout UX Features Users can easily track milestones and progress of their real estate transactions. Secure document signing simplifies and speeds up the process. User guidance features to assist new users and enhance the overall experience. 3. Standout CX Features The streamlined onboarding process makes it easy to get started. Secure communication and efficient transactions build trust. The app provides value by simplifying and securing real estate transactions. By focusing on user-friendly navigation, appealing visual elements, and efficient transaction processes, the inHere app stands out as a model of innovation within the industry. It demonstrates how attention to detail in UI and UX features can directly enhance the overall customer experience (CX), making real estate transactions smoother and more secure. This case study serves as a powerful testament to the value of a holistic approach in digital product design, where each element works synergistically to improve customer satisfaction and engagement. Enhancing User Experience in an E-commerce Digital Product Artifact Uprising offers a creative and emotionally gratifying experience for transforming digital photos into personalized art. 1. Standout UI Features A simple and functional interface provides intuitive photo upload and design tools. The interface is user-friendly and visually appealing. 2. Standout UX Features The app enables effortless image uploading from various sources. The design platform allows for easy customization and creativity. Features enhance the joy of creating personalized mementos. 3. Standout CX Features The app clearly introduces its unique selling points (USP) and value proposition. There is easy-to-access customer support for quick problem-solving. The app provides value by making creating tangible memories enjoyable and convenient. The Importance of UI, UX, & CX in Digital Products The app design process isn’t just about pretty colors and cool animations. It’s about crafting a beautiful interface (UI) that users love and a smooth experience (UX) that keeps them coming back. But it goes deeper than that—creating a positive and memorable relationship with your customers (CX). InspiringApps’ designers work with businesses to turn ideas into a complete app that looks great, works well, and leaves a lasting impression. Businesses can better shape their digital products and improve customer journeys by applying our holistic approach to UI/UX design and customer experience. A carefully curated blend of UI, UX, and CX sets the stage for a successful app that users will adore.

5 months ago

Blog Categories
App Design
App Marketing
Business & Strategy
Client Projects
Culture & Innovation
Digital Product Development
Digital Products
Events
InspiringApps News
Mobile Industry
Technology
Webinars